AI Search in 2025: Why We Should Integrate, Not Overthink, SEO, AEO & GEO

28 May 2025

By: James Gray, VP of Digital Marketing

Category: Digital Marketing

The way we discover content, products and even brands online is changing. Fast. With AI reshaping the mechanics of search, new frameworks like Answer Engine Optimisation (AEO) and Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) have entered many digital marketer’s vocabulary. But while these recent evolutions are significant, the answer isn’t to abandon SEO (and focus on the shiny new acronyms); it’s to adapt it.

There’s a clear need to understand how these frameworks differ and where they overlap. Yet there’s also a risk of over-engineering strategies that miss the bigger picture. At its core, it’s still about visibility, trust, and relevance.

In this article, VP Digital Marketing, James Gray, will explain what the differences are between SEO, AEO and GEO and how your business can adapt for the new state of AI-powered search.

Clarifying the Concepts: SEO, AEO and GEO

What is Search Engine Optimisation (SEO)? SEO is the practice of increasing website visibility in search engine results pages (SERPs) to attract organic traffic. 

What is Answer Engine Optimisation (AEO)? AEO involves creating content designed to provide direct answers to user queries, aiming to feature in SERP elements like Featured Snippets, People Also Ask boxes, or voice search responses (the artist formerly known as ‘Position 0’ – anything above the traditional fabled ‘blue links’). 

What is Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO)? GEO involves optimising content for AI-powered platforms, such as ChatGPT, Google’s AI Overviews, or Perplexity, which generate summarised responses based on multiple data sources. 

The State of AI Search: What the Numbers Say

Despite the surge in AI hype, the data tells a more tempered story. According to research: 

  • Only 1–2% of website traffic currently comes from generative AI tools like ChatGPT. 
  • 98.1% of ChatGPT desktop users still also use Google, suggesting AI hasn’t replaced traditional search, it’s supplementing it. Similarly, 98.2% of Perplexity visitors are shared with Google, leaving only 1.8% exclusive.  
  • Google continues to see over 5 trillion searches annually, with a growth rate of more than 20% in the last two years.

Chart showing websites and their organic search traffic in April 2025 versus their AI traffic in April 2025

Chart showing audience overlap between Google and ChatGPT and another chart showing website's audience loyalty comparison between Google and ChatGPT

At the same time, AI Overviews and zero-click search results are on the rise. Google’s new AI-generated summaries aim to give users answers without needing to click through to a website. That means even if your content contributes to an AI answer, you might not see traffic from it. If Google can keep your entire visit in their ecosystem, they will.  

The Trade-Off: Visibility Without the Click

This trend is important. Recent findings show that click-through rates have dropped in search results where AI Overviews appear. This presents a visibility paradox: your content might be referenced, even quoted, but the user doesn’t always make it to your site. 

So, is that a loss? 

Not entirely. This is where brand visibility takes centre stage. Appearing in AI-generated summaries, even without clicks, still reinforces brand credibility, especially when users encounter your brand across platforms. A useful currency in a noisy landscape. 

Your brand becomes the destination – not just the website.  

Brands should look to adapt from just “ranking in results” to “being the answer.” That requires trust-building content, strong entity optimisation and consistent brand signals across your entire digital presence. 

The Role of Perplexity & Other AI-First Discovery Tools 

While Google’s AI Overviews are zero-click by design (although you can still find some links/citation), tools like Perplexity offer a slightly different dynamic. Perplexity cites sources more explicitly and links users to the exact sites where its summaries are drawn from. In some cases, it can increase traffic for publishers, especially when your content is seen as authoritative and well-structured. 

Other AI discovery platforms, like You.com or Brave Search, are following similar models. This means: 

  • Your content needs to be credible and well-attributed. 
  • Structured data, citations, and clarity help ensure AI tools reference you accurately. 
  • Being referenced builds long-term brand equity, even if immediate click-through is lower. 

AEO and GEO: Not Just Buzzwords

AEO and GEO aren’t here to replace SEO, they’re here to extend it. 

  • AEO enhances traditional SEO by structuring content around questions and intent-based answers. 
  • GEO acknowledges that content is now being interpreted and summarised by AI, not just indexed by a crawler. 

If your content isn’t clear, structured, or contextually rich, AI tools may ignore it, or worse, misrepresent it. That’s where GEO becomes critical: making your content machine-readable and semantically sound.

AI rendering of an SEO screen in front of a person typing on a keyboard

A Practical Approach: Integrating, Not Overhauling

You don’t need to throw away your SEO playbook. But you do need to evolve it. 

Here are five key considerations: 

  1. Maintain strong SEO fundamentals – Relevant, original, technically sound content is still the foundation. 
  2. Optimise for clarity and structure – Use subheadings, bullet points, FAQs, and schema markup. Help AI and search engines understand you. 
  3. Focus on entity and brand signals – Establish your brand as a trusted source across multiple channels. Make it easy for AI to associate topics with your brand. 
  4. Adapt content for answers, not just rankings – Anticipate questions. Provide clear, concise, authoritative answers. 
  5. Monitor AI search performance – Tools like Oncrawl, Similarweb, and Semrush can help you understand where AI is referencing your content and where visibility may not translate into traffic. 

Are you ready for the Future of Search?

AEO and GEO are not silver bullets, nor are they distractions. They’re the next logical steps in how we think about discoverability. 

Clicks still matter, but in a world of AI summaries, being cited, seen, and trusted matters more. Brand is becoming the new SERP position. 

So, yes – optimise for the click. But also optimise for the answer. 

And above all, optimise for the user. Whether they visit your site, see your logo in an AI Overview, or find your insight summarised in their assistant of choice. 

We’re helping clients understand their visibility in the future of search. If you’d like to explore how you are presented in AI-powered search and cited in LLMs, as well as how you can improve the likelihood of being found through these new discovery experiences, get in touch.

Remarkable are one of the world’s leading digital experience agencies. As a double Platinum Sitecore and Optimizely partner, we offer technology solutions to help brands build experiences that convert.

Go back